Up to this point, we’ve “just said no”. But too many of you, and your clients, have asked about how to “go green” in their investments. So let’s dive into the weeds (oops, we did it again) of marijuana investing and whether it’s a good investment or just a good story.
There are several reasons we are seeing overall growth in the marijuana industry. For one, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, the most recent tally shows that ten states and the District of Columbia have legalized small amounts of marijuana for adult recreational use while in 2018, an additional 21 states considered bills for legalization. In short, pot smoking does not have the same stigma it once had and there are entire industries (both new and old) trying to take advantage of this trend.
For the purpose of this piece, our focus is on the review of public investments (mutual funds and ETFs specifically). While we acknowledge there are other direct, non-public ways to invest in the marijuana industry, we would argue that each of these opportunities deserve their own review, keeping in mind many of the points made in this post may still apply.
Like any investment, understanding the economic rationale is critical before investing. Marijuana investing is expected to be a growth industry, which clearly has some appeal. However, it is critical to look at the actual holdings of the available pooled-vehicle (i.e. ETF) investments. Similarly, as this is a niche investment, having appropriate risk and return expectations is important as well.
Currently (as of June 30, 2019), there are only two marijuana-related ETFs available today in the United States, MJ and YOLO.
MJ (ETFMG Alternative Harvest ETF) has an inception date of 12/3/15 and has over $1B AUM. But there is a catch. Prior to December 26, 2017, the fund was called the Tierra XP Latin America Real Estate ETF, obviously something very different from what it is today. A cynic could argue its distributor changed course due to lack of success in real estate (and low AUM) and instead created this marijuana ETF in order to gain first-mover advantage, something that has traditionally been pretty helpful in the ETF industry. It is a relatively concentrated portfolio with roughly 40 stocks, with only eight holdings comprising just over 50% of the portfolio weight (source: etfmj.com, 4/24/19). It’s also more of an indirect way to get exposure to the marijuana industry, with its investments in pharmaceutical, tobacco and even fertilizer companies. In addition, it is a passively managed product and while we are generally a large proponent of passive investing, we question if this is the right approach in an ever-changing landscape.
YOLO (AdvisorShares Pure Cannabis ETF) is brand new to the marketplace with an inception date of 4/17/19; therefore, it has no track record and very few assets. It does, however, have a few positive attributes going for it. For one, it is more of a pure-play cannabis investment as it is expected to hold securities with at least 50% of their revenue coming from the marijuana and hemp business. In addition, it is an actively managed product, so the goal would be for the portfolio manager to be able to successfully maneuver through the fast-paced changes of the industry. Finally, BNY Mellon is serving as the custodian for YOLO, lending some legitimacy to the holding as it’s the first major custodian to support a marijuana ETF.
In looking at the marijuana industry and its growth potential, there are several risks and other items to consider before investing, some of which we have already mentioned. One key point to remember is that marijuana is still an illegal and federally banned substance. Without having the blessing of the federal government, there are still potential legal ramifications associated with marijuana-linked companies. Other considerations include the pace of growth in this industry (some have likened it to the wild west) as well as the fact that it’s a niche investment, something we don’t often promote.
We also spoke to major ETF and fund providers including SPDRs, BlackRock and Vanguard about their potential for investment in this industry. Not surprisingly, due to their need to be invested in large and liquid markets, along with the fact that marijuana is still federally illegal, there doesn’t appear to be any new marijuana ETFs likely coming from a major provider in the near future. Other providers believe the current attention on marijuana investing is being driven more by sentiment than valuation and would argue the current valuations for marijuana-related holdings are too high (again, sorry for the pun).
What is our opinion on marijuana ETFs? We’ll be blunt (promise, this is the last pun). While this is clearly an interesting story and one that we will continue to monitor as it develops, we currently recommend sitting on the sidelines and waiting for some maturity, from a regulatory, product, and industry standpoint. If you read this position statement and determine that an investment is still right for you or your clients, we would suggest keeping it a relatively small portion of any growth-oriented portfolio.
About the Authors
About the Mardio Nardone, CFA
Mario began his investment career in 1999 with Vanguard mutual funds in Valley Forge, PA, where he consulted institutions and financial advisors on investment policy, portfolio construction, and Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs). He also held roles as a research analyst, a municipal bond fund specialist, among others during his tenure. In 2003 he earned the Chartered Financial Analyst designation, and he continues to mentor aspiring Charter candidates and young investment professionals.
Mario relocated to Charleston in 2010 to serve as Chief Investment Officer for a financial planning firm before establishing East Bay, the collaborative partner firm of (insert firm name), in 2014. As a Partner at East Bay, Mario serves a select group of Registered Investment Advisor firms as their outsourced Chief Investment Strategist. Responsibilities of this role include continuous oversight of advisor clients’ investments, bespoke strategies for unique situations, client communications, and more.
Mario is Past President of CFA Society South Carolina and Former Chairman of the College of Charleston Finance Department Advisory Board. His approach to investments and the industry has been featured in Investment News, NAPFA Advisor Magazine, South Carolina Public Radio, and other publications and media outlets.
Mario enjoys early morning basketball games, the Charleston beaches and restaurant scene, and spending summers in coastal Maine. He is an avid world traveler and SCUBA diver, but also enjoys the simpler joys of life with his wife Piper, their daughter Pepper, and son Santino.
Learn more and connect with Mario on LinkedIn.
About Eric Stein, CFA
Eric Stein, CFA, joined East Bay Financial Services in 2018 and brings his passion for investing and client service with him. He enjoys sharing his knowledge and experiences with colleagues and clients.
Prior to joining East Bay, Eric has worked for a variety of firms both large and small. This includes 7+ years with Goldman Sachs Asset Management where he held roles in areas such as performance measurement, client service, risk analysis and portfolio construction. He also served as the Chief Investment Officer for RSM U.S. Wealth Management for 10+ years, providing strategic leadership and solutions for their national investment platform.
Eric is a proud graduate of Indiana University where he earned a B.S. in Finance. He also earned the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation in 2001 and continues to stay involved in the local society.
This information is provided “AS IS” and without warranties of any kind either express or implied. To the fullest extent permissible pursuant to applicable laws, XY Investment Solutions, LLC (referred to as "XYIS") disclaims all warranties, express or implied, including, but not limited to, implied warranties of merchantability, non-infringement and suitability for a particular purpose. XYIS does not warrant that the information will be free from error. None of the information provided is intended as investment, tax, accounting or legal advice, as an offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or as an endorsement of any company, security, fund, or other securities or non-securities offering. The information should not be relied upon for purposes of transacting securities or other investments. Your use of the information is at your sole risk. Under no circumstances shall XYIS be liable for any direct, indirect, special or consequential damages that result from the use of, or the inability to use, the materials in this site, even if XYIS or an XYIS authorized representative has been advised of the possibility of such damages. In no event shall XY Investment Solutions, LLC have any liability to you for damages, losses and causes of action for this information. This information should not be considered a solicitation to buy, an offer to sell, or a recommendation of any security in any jurisdiction where such offer, solicitation, or recommendation would be unlawful or unauthorized.
Subscribe by email
You May Also Like
These Related Stories