One Fee, Two Services: Combining Investment Management and Financial Planning Fees
Share this
A growing number of financial advisors understand and embrace the importance of including comprehensive financial planning in their suite of services. With this recognition comes the need to simplify fee payments and invoicing for clients.
At a glance, it would seem that the most effective way to accomplish this is to combine both services into one fee. There are apparent advantages to having the client pay only one fee for both the advisor and the client.
For the advisor, it simplifies the billing and invoicing process and streamlines payment processing. For the client, this method may appear more transparent and may be easier for the client to plan for and track their household expenses.
Unfortunately there are some regulatory hurdles that require the attention of financial planners planning to implement this payment structure.
Failure of Regulators to View Financial Planning as a Separate and Distinct Service
One of the biggest challenges that compliance officers of financial planning focused firms face is trying to get regulators to adopt a proper view of financial planning services. Many regulators are so stuck in the AUM mind frame that they refuse to see the value in financial planning outside of investment management services.
Some regulators have gone so far as to declare that “A good investment manager will automatically include financial planning services for their clients, and therefore shouldn’t charge separately for it.”
This type of commentary minimizes the practice of financial planning at best, and at worst asserts that there is no value at all that should be assigned to comprehensive financial planning.
Consequently, when advisors attempt to combine AUM and financial planning services into one fee for the client, regulators struggle to determine what portion of the fee is being assessed for each service. This often leads to a regulatory preference for hourly financial planning services due to the failure of regulators to adopt a more holistic regulatory view of the service.
As a result, it is not uncommon for regulators to require advisors to charge clients separately for comprehensive financial planning services and AUM.
Inability of Regulators to Rely on Traditional Audit Procedures
When it comes to compliance, one thing rings true across most firms: the audit process is a major source of anxiety for firm owners.
Regulatory offices have documented procedures for how audits and examinations are to be conducted. In terms of fees, billing, and invoicing, these procedures rely heavily on mathematical calculations.
Traditional practices involve accessing the firm’s ADV and advisory contracts and invoices and calculating the fee that the client should be charged. This calculation involves assessing the amount of assets in a client’s account “as of” a particular date and applying the fee in basis points to the AUM, and then dividing the result by the total number of payments occurring throughout the year.
For regulators, either this number is correct, or it’s not. No shades of gray here.
But what happens when the financial planning fee is included in the calculation? What was a simple mathematical equation becomes a seemingly ambiguous set of numbers for which there is no apparent rationale.
Therein lies the issue.
From this point, the regulator has to determine what portion of the fee is assigned to financial planning services and what portion of the fee is assigned to AUM. When the examiner is unable to do so, the burden of proof shifts to the firm, and it becomes the responsibility of the firm to effectively articulate the proper calculation so that the invoice and firm deposits can be properly evaluated.
Moreover, the firm will also have to establish some level of consistency in billing practices, which becomes complicated by the process of adjusting financial planning fees based on complexity and needs of the client. From the regulator’s perspective, it becomes nearly impossible to establish a determination on fair and equitable billing practices.
This problem can be avoided by charging separately for the services and receiving separately executed client contracts. The downside, of course, is that the client will see two separate fees.
Unwillingness of Regulators to Learn More About the Financial Planning Process
Realistically, it’s not hard to understand why regulators appear unwilling to learn more about the financial planning process. Regulators are employees of an institution and they receive a certain compensation to do their job. Taking the initiative to learn more about the financial planning process requires additional work—work for which they are unlikely to receive additional compensation.
Drafting regulations and creating audit procedures specifically for financial planning services is a laborious task. And again, I doubt there will be corresponding pay increases or resources devoted from regulatory offices to fulfill this purpose.
Understanding this may help firms exercise the patience needed to facilitate these conversations and the flexibility needed to achieve the goal of providing financial planning services. Fortunately, as financial planning services continue to expand, regulators will be forced to deal with the growing number of advisors looking for client-friendly, efficient, and effective methods to provide real financial planning to their clients.
About the Author
Scott is a licensed Securities Principal with experience in both RIA and broker-dealer compliance. He began his financial services career in 2006 as a Registered Representative with E*Trade Financial in Alpharetta, GA. He has also worked with J.P. Morgan Private Banking in Chicago, IL and with Wells Fargo Advisors in Chapel Hill, NC.
Scott’s most recent role before joining Team XYPN was as Compliance Officer of Carolinas Investment Consulting, in Charlotte NC. He’s a graduate of The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and holds FINRA Series 63, 65, 24, 4 and 53 Licenses.
Scott lives in Charlotte, NC with his wife Meredith, and their two sons Tyson and Jackson and daughter Eva. In his free time, Scott enjoys watching sports, exercising, and operating the charitable organization he created upon his father’s passing.
You can connect with him on LinkedIn.
Share this
- Advisor Posts (420)
- Fee-only advisor (364)
- Advice (302)
- Blog (297)
- Independent Financial Advisor (191)
- Fee-for-service Financial Planning (133)
- Business Development (125)
- Running a Firm (107)
- Marketing (94)
- What Would Arlene Say (WWAS) (81)
- Practice Management (77)
- Training (76)
- Firm Ownership (75)
- Executive Coaching (70)
- Business (69)
- Business Coach (68)
- Building a Firm (64)
- Compliance (63)
- Financial Planning Firm (63)
- Growing Your Firm (61)
- Financial Advisors (56)
- XYPN LIVE (53)
- RIA Marketing (50)
- From XYPN Members (47)
- RIA Compliance (47)
- Starting a Firm (47)
- Technology (44)
- Fee-only Financial Planning (39)
- Advisors (38)
- Entrepreneurship (38)
- Marketing Your Firm (38)
- Prospecting (36)
- Conference (35)
- XY Tax Solutions (XYTS) (34)
- Tax Planning (32)
- Interviews and Case Studies (31)
- Investment Management (31)
- Marketing Strategy (30)
- Growing Business (29)
- Launching a firm (28)
- XY Investment Solutions (XYIS) (27)
- Tax Preparation (26)
- Business Owner (25)
- Business Strategy (25)
- Managing a Firm (24)
- Team Building (23)
- Marketing Funnel (22)
- Diversity (21)
- Annual Conference (20)
- Getting Clients (20)
- Sales (20)
- Small Business Owner (20)
- Social Media (20)
- Financial Planning Conference (19)
- Marketing Resources (18)
- Business Model (17)
- Chief Compliance Officer (COO) (17)
- Client Relationships (17)
- Content Marketing (17)
- Financial Planners (17)
- From XYIS (17)
- Hiring (16)
- Independent Financial Planner (16)
- Niche Marketing (16)
- Setting Goals (16)
- Tax Savings (16)
- Website Development (16)
- XYPN News (16)
- Business Vision (15)
- Sales Process (15)
- Business Growth (14)
- Email Marketing (14)
- Financial Advice (14)
- Networking (14)
- Media (13)
- Press Mentions (13)
- RIA (13)
- Tax (13)
- XYPN (13)
- Advertising (12)
- Goals (12)
- Assets Under Management (AUM) (11)
- First Year (11)
- Investing (11)
- Next Generation Financial Planning (11)
- Niche (11)
- RIA Owner (11)
- Sales Pipeline (11)
- Current Events (10)
- Filing Taxes (10)
- Financial Coaching (10)
- Taxes (10)
- Year-End Tax Planning (10)
- Advisor Success (9)
- Client Management (9)
- Fintech (9)
- Inbound Marketing (9)
- Communication (8)
- How to be a Financial Advisor (8)
- SEC (8)
- Study Group (8)
- Time Management (8)
- XYPN Membership (8)
- Branding (7)
- Digital Content (7)
- Financial Planning Fees (7)
- Financial Planning Process (7)
- Lessons (7)
- Mental Health (7)
- Pricing Models (7)
- RIA Registration (7)
- Virtual Advisor (7)
- Business Plan (6)
- From Our Advisors (6)
- Growth (6)
- Mentorship (6)
- Motivation (6)
- Risk and Investing (6)
- Tax Season (6)
- Abundance Mentality (5)
- Advisor Website (5)
- Automation (5)
- Behavioral Finance (5)
- Client Experience (5)
- Client Service Model (5)
- Clients (5)
- Connection (5)
- Filing Status (5)
- Financial Planning (5)
- Inclusion (5)
- Investment Planner (5)
- Marketing Plan (5)
- Michael Kitces (5)
- Outsourced Tax Services (5)
- Processes (5)
- Racism (5)
- Real Financial Planning (5)
- Retirement (5)
- S Corpration (5)
- Support System (5)
- TAMP (5)
- Tax Return (5)
- Transitioning Advisor (5)
- Wealth (5)
- Bear Market (4)
- Broker-Dealers (4)
- CFP Certification (4)
- College Planning (4)
- Continuing Education (4)
- Independent RIA (4)
- Lead nurturing (4)
- Marketing Coaching (4)
- Money Management (4)
- Online Marketing (4)
- Outsourcing (4)
- Professional Development (4)
- Scaling Firms (4)
- Search Engine Optimization (SEO) (4)
- Selling a Firm (4)
- Small Business (4)
- Succession Plans (4)
- Tax Forms (4)
- Transitioning Clients (4)
- Virtual Meetings & Events (4)
- XYPN Radio (4)
- Year-End (4)
- AdvisorTech Expo (3)
- Annual Review Process (3)
- Budgeting (3)
- Client Avatars (3)
- Community (3)
- Company Culture (3)
- ESG Investing (3)
- Emotional Decisions (3)
- Engagement (3)
- Fiduciary (3)
- Financial Life Planning (3)
- Getting Leads (3)
- Google Analytics (3)
- How to be a Successful Entrepreneur (3)
- IRA (3)
- Industry Trends (3)
- Initial Sales Call (3)
- Life planning (3)
- Lifestyle practice (3)
- Market Volatility (3)
- Membership (3)
- Monthly Retainer Model (3)
- Paid Marketing (3)
- Partnership (3)
- Pricing (3)
- RIA Audit (3)
- Recordkeeping (3)
- Risk Assessment (3)
- Scaling Up (3)
- Staying Relevant (3)
- Tax Extension (3)
- Tax Firm (3)
- Tech Stack (3)
- Unhappy Clients (3)
- Value Proposition (3)
- Wellness (3)
- Work Life Balance (3)
- Workplace Issues (3)
- Advice-Only Planning (2)
- Benchmarking Study (2)
- Certified Public Accountant (CPA) (2)
- Changemaker (2)
- Charity (2)
- Coaching (2)
- Community Property (2)
- Conflict Management (2)
- Design (2)
- Differentiation (2)
- Employee Benefits (2)
- Entrepreneurial Operating System (EOS) (2)
- Exchange-Traded Funds (ETF) (2)
- FINRA (2)
- Feminism (2)
- Finding Your Why (2)
- George Kinder (2)
- Graphic design (2)
- Growing Income (2)
- Health Care (2)
- Ideal Clients (2)
- Inflation (2)
- Investment Adviser Representative (IAR) (2)
- Key performance indicator (KPI) (2)
- Keynote (2)
- Learning (2)
- Local Meet-ups (2)
- Market Downturn (2)
- Mastermind Group (2)
- Members (2)
- Monthly Subscription Model (2)
- Negative Rates (2)
- Organization (2)
- Outsourced Asset Management (2)
- Personality Types (2)
- Portfolio Management (2)
- Productivity (2)
- Psychology (2)
- Recommended Reading (2)
- Registered Representative (2)
- Registration (2)
- Restricted Stock Units (RSU) (2)
- Scott Snider (2)
- Solo Advisor (2)
- Start Ups (2)
- State Registration (2)
- Stock Options (2)
- Target Market (2)
- Tax Refund (2)
- Team Communication (2)
- Value of Financial Planning (2)
- Video Production (2)
- Virtual Assistant (2)
- Virtual Paraplanner (2)
- Yields (2)
- Accounting (1)
- Advisory Board (1)
- Analogies (1)
- Anti-harassment (1)
- Arlene Moss (1)
- Assistant (1)
- Behavior Gap (1)
- Bonds (1)
- Books and Records (1)
- Broker Protocol (1)
- Broker Recruiting (1)
- Bull Market (1)
- Buying a Firm (1)
- Career Changers (1)
- Careers (1)
- Carl Richards (1)
- Carolyn Dalle-Molle (1)
- Cassandra Worthy (1)
- Charitable Donations (1)
- Charitable Giving (1)
- Childcare (1)
- Compassion (1)
- Consulting (1)
- Consumerism (1)
- Continuity Plan (1)
- Creatives (1)
- Credit (1)
- Cryptocurrency (1)
- Custodians (1)
- Custody Rule (1)
- Dan Sullivan (1)
- Definitions (1)
- Designations (1)
- Direct Indexing (1)
- Disasters (1)
- Dr. Sean Stephenson (1)
- Earn More (1)
- Education (1)
- Elizabeth Dunn (1)
- Enrolled Agent (EA) (1)
- Entity Election (1)
- Entrepreneur Myth (1)
- Equity (1)
- Event Planning (1)
- Events (1)
- Family (1)
- Fee-Based Financial Planning (1)
- Fidelity (1)
- FinTech Winner (1)
- Finance (1)
- Financial Freedom (1)
- Financial Goals (1)
- Financial Life Management (1)
- Financial Planning Platform (1)
- Financial Preparedness (1)
- Financial Wellness (1)
- Form 8606 (1)
- Form 8915-E (1)
- Form ADV (1)
- Gen X (1)
- Gen Y (1)
- Google Search Ads (1)
- Graduates (1)
- Grief (1)
- Guide (1)
- How I Did It series (1)
- How to Budget (1)
- Human Resources (HR) (1)
- Impact Investing (1)
- Impostor Syndrome (1)
- International financial planning (1)
- Interns (1)
- Introverts (1)
- Investor Policy Statement (IPS) (1)
- Job burnout (1)
- Job description (1)
- Job posting (1)
- LLC (1)
- Lead conversion (1)
- Lending (1)
- Liquidating your business (1)
- Loans (1)
- Merging Practices (1)
- Michael Gerber (1)
- Miguel Gomez (1)
- Millennials (1)
- Mission (1)
- Moira Somers (1)
- Moving Forward (1)
- New Planner Recruiting (1)
- NextGen (1)
- NextGen Clients (1)
- Online Courses (1)
- Orion (1)
- Part Time (1)
- Paying Yourself (1)
- Paystub (1)
- Perfectionism (1)
- Professionals (1)
- Project Management (1)
- Projecting Returns (1)
- Purpose (1)
- Quarterly Estimated Payments (1)
- ROI (1)
- Recession (1)
- Recruiting (1)
- Referrals (1)
- Regulators (1)
- Reinvention (1)
- Relationships (1)
- Remote (1)
- Required Minimum Distributions (RMD) (1)
- Retreats (1)
- Risk Management (1)
- Roth Conversations (1)
- Roth IRA (1)
- SEC Regulation S-P (1)
- Sabbatical (1)
- Saying No (1)
- Scaling (1)
- Schedule Management (1)
- Schwab (1)
- Sean Stephenson (1)
- Sequence Risk (1)
- Slow Season (1)
- Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) (1)
- Spending (1)
- Stop Saying Should (1)
- Strategy (1)
- Supervisory Procedures (1)
- Supporting Clients (1)
- Systems (1)
- Target Audience (1)
- Teamwork (1)
- Terms (1)
- Tim Maurer (1)
- To-Do List (1)
- Total Return Approach (1)
- Traditional IRA (1)
- Transitions (1)
- Virtual (1)
- Vulnerability (1)
- WRAP Programs (1)
- Women (1)
- XY Learning Center (XYLC) (1)
Subscribe by email
You May Also Like
These Related Stories

Three Compliance Goals You Should Set for Your Financial Planning Firm

Identifying and Disclosing Conflicts of Interest: A How-To for Financial Advisors
